Objective-C libraries and Unix philosophy
· 2 minute read
Caleb Davenport recently asked the following question on Twitter:
Is there a small CocoaPod that does NSDictionary to and from form encoded string and nothing else?— Caleb Davenport (@calebd) January 21, 2014
He knew that this functionality already exists in a number of larger libraries, but couldn’t find exactly what he was looking for; something that did query string serialization correctly and nothing else. So he made it.
I’ve long adored the Node.js community in part for their steadfast belief that modules in NPM should embody the Unix philosophy of “do one thing and do it well.” Node modules are championed if they export a single function and deemed to be inadequate if they expose more surface area than is needed.
For this very reason, a shift towards building more focused, modular Objective-C libraries should be welcomed. Small modules allow even the most conservative of developers to benefit by including open-source components that are easy to understand, thoroughly tested, and expose only the most pertinent of APIs. The more a library does, the harder it is to understand what it’s doing and how well it’s doing it, making it less likely to be used and far less valuable to the community as a whole.
In my experience, small modules also foster much better collaboration. It’s easy to be tentative about contributing to a large library, as it’s harder to fully understand the architectural underpinnings and how the maintainer plans to structure it as it evolves. Caleb’s library, to the contrary, was so small in scope that I felt comfortable opening a pull request almost immediately. Small modules have explicit goals which makes it easy for others to help.
Has CocoaPods played a role in this shift? I think so. Though CocoaPods allows one to publish a sprawling monolith as easily as it does a single function, lower barriers to create and consume libraries is a win for modularity in general. The more painful it is to integrate a dependency, the fewer times you’ll opt to do so, making larger libraries seem attractive. CocoaPods makes integration so easy that there’s no excuse not to break your code up into small modules.
Creating a Objective-C library will always have more overhead than for example, a Node module, due to header files, project files, etc. But I’m thrilled with the direction that we seem to be moving in as a community.